I've got a straight 7 blade, 18 inch salad chopper that came with Gertrude, another 6 blade one from Mathilda, and have but a week ago put a clutched 7 blade 18 inch fan on Gertrude. The straight fan sat just 0.25 inches from the radiator, sans shroud. Same with Mathilda when I got her w the 6 blade fan. These cars didn't always come with shrouds.
I fabricated a NICE shroud for Mathilda last Spring, but we know what came of it later that summer. It helped, but the cheap A Team electric fan helped more. For the dollar, I find this to be so, and will stick by that assessment.
7 blade fans move PLENTY air, when they're turning, but I'm more apt than ever to be RID of mech fans altogether and might even ditch the clutch fan I just installed, if the nice new FFD 3600 I installed a couple days ago will do for it well enough.
Mind you all, 75% of my time behind the wheel is in urban traffic under 40 mph, so electric cooling makes more sense in this environment. On the highway, a clutch fan certainly pulls air, though once rolling above ~40 mph, the headwind will cool the radiator nicely without any fan.
For now, I've saturated the amount of air I can push or pull through that radiator, and am looking into increasing the flow rate at low rpm. The non-AC, 4.375" 8 blade impeller iron pump I installed with the clutched salad chopper moves coolant a bit quicker, which has helped reduce my average running temperature by 15 degrees Fahrenheit, when rolling.