I actually had something very similar to this happen to me years ago. If the switch in a 69 is made in a similar fashion to a 68. I believe the buttons on my switch are laid out from left to right off/heat/ac/max ac/def. Mine would also work in the ac modes, but not heat and def. The back of the switch came loose so when I would push the buttons the only ones that would activate the electrical part of the switch were the ac modes. It drove me nuts for sometime.
From this picture that I grabbed from ebay it looks to be the exact same type of construction.
The darker piece came loose and would let there be a good electrical connection.
I hope this helps.